MAKING BRITISH BOTANY
Elizabeth Dale was a student at Girton College from 1887-91, completing her studies four years before Harry Marshall Ward was appointed Professor of Botany. However, her connection with Cambridge, and particularly with Girton, extended over many years. Following her ‘graduation’, there is a period lasting until 1897 during which relatively little is known about her life. In 1897 she became a ‘Botany Assistant’ in The Balfour Laboratory for Women, for the first two years being supported by a Pfeiffer Studentship worth £40 p.a.. The Assistantship required her to help teach undergraduate practical classes but allowed her time free to conduct research. In 1914 she left The Balfour, becoming Garden Steward at her old college (a post she had held part-time during the previous two years).
Elizabeth’s father, John Gallemore Dale, died in 1871 when she was three years old and he was only 31. He had been a member of the chemical manufacturing firm Roberts, Dale, and Co, established in Warrington in 1852, and specialising in dyes and inks. Her mother, Clara, married again, to Robert Bennett, a ‘merchant engineer’, twelve years her junior. At age 13 Elizabeth Dale was living in Withington (now Greater Manchester) with her ‘new’ family. She was educated at home with a governess but, at some point, moved to a private school in Buxton, Derbyshire, a county whose geology was to prove an inspiration to her.
After a brief spell at Owens College, Manchester (the future Manchester University, where Marshall Ward had been both a student, 1875, and a teacher, 1883-86 – he latterly lived in Withington), Elizabeth Dale entered Girton College. It was as a post-graduate that Dale encountered Marshall Ward, their Mancunian backgrounds providing a ready connection. Dale’s first publication was jointly with Marshall Ward in the Journal of the Linnean Society (1898); the subject, Craterostigma pumilum, was a rare plant from Somali-Land (sic) presented to the Botanic Garden by a traveller in Africa. Thereafter, she published on her own though often, as in her 1901 paper in the Annals of Botany, thanking him “…for allowing me to work in the University Botanical Laboratory, and for the help which he always so willingly gives”. It was Marshall Ward, Fellow of the Royal Society, who communicated her lengthy and beautifully illustrated paper to the Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, read in 1905 and published shortly before his death in 1906. Unsurprisingly, given Marshall Ward’s oversight of her early career, her first publications were on aspects of plant pathology. However, Dale continued to publish until 1914 when, writing on the subject of soil fungi and published in Annales Mycologici, she described herself as “Garden Steward, Girton College”.
Elizabeth Dale’s interest in geology was mentioned briefly above. In 1900 she published a small book (176pp.), Scenery and Geology of the Peak of Derbyshire (Sampson Low, Marston & Co. Ltd.). Its reviewer in Nature was not altogether complimentary, doubting “… the wisdom of introducing so much general geology in what is essentially a local guide”. In a remark aimed more at the publisher than at Dale, the reviewer added, “The book has a somewhat provincial aspect in its ‘get up’”. She did not again publish a major work on the subject of geology, confining herself to minor observations in the Glacialists’ Magazine. On returning to Cambridge in 1897, she was a member of the Sedgwick Club (for geologists) for the next six years, on four occasions joining their field trips, each lasting several days.
The gap between ‘graduation’ and her return to Cambridge is probably explained in part by Dale living with her family in Buxton while studying the geology of the Peak District and preparing her book. She kept in touch with the Cambridge geologists, and broadened her geological horizons, for in 1890, 1891, 1892, and 1893 she joined departmental field trips organised by the Sedgwick Club to, respectively, the Lake District, Plas Tan Y Bwlch, the Malverns, and the Isle of Man. In 1893 she also attended the annual meeting of the British Association for the Advancement of Science (BAAS), held that year in Nottingham (she is also listed among attendees at the 1899 meeting, held in Dover).
Wherever she went Elizabeth Dale was as interested in the flora as much as the geology. The Buxton Museum and Art Gallery holds her collection of herbarium specimens. By visiting online, “Collections in the Landscape”, one can see the well-preserved Wood Anemone she collected when 16 years old. The collection she made between 1884 and 1897 reflects her travels; while 45 specimens come from Derbyshire, two come from the Isle of Man (1893), and there is even one from Paris (1886). By the time of her last publications she was almost inevitably studying soil fungi, thereby drawing upon her extensive knowledge of both plants and soil types.
Returning to the subject of field trips, Elizabeth Dale makes a connection with Arthur Tansley and his mother, Amelia (elsewhere on this site).
Archiveshub.jisc.ac.uk. Ref: GB590 SGWC 2/2/10, shows that on the 1892 excursion Sedgwick to the Malverns (27 June to 6 July), both Elizabeth and her sister, Clara G Dale, were present together with AG Tawsley (sic) - who is also mentioned in the text.
Ref: GB590 SGWC 2/2/11 tells that on the 1893 excursion to the Isle of Man, Elizabeth Dale and Arthur G Tamley (sic) were present. (This fits with the young Arthur George Tansley having taken geology in his second year at Cambridge, 1891-2, and at the end of that year having been on field trips with Professor McKenny Hughes. In 1893 he completed Part I of the Tripos, geology being one of his subjects). The website, “Women in the Sedgwick Museum Archive. Being Seen and Heard”, reproduces a letter, dated 4 October, 1893, from Elizabeth Dale to Mrs McKenny Hughes in which she writes that she was recently at a meeting of the BAAS in Nottingham together with her sister and Mrs Tansley. Mrs Tansley and Mr Tansley then spent the rest of September with Elizabeth in Buxton. Mr Tansley helped (Patty ???) develop photographs taken on the Isle of Man field trip held earlier that year.
Why was Mrs Tansley at the BAAS meeting in 1893, during his vacation? She may have been a ’clinging’ mother; he was her favourite child; in other years they visited the Wagner Festival in Bayreuth during his holidays. And how did she know Elizabeth and Clara Dale so well that she was invited to stay at Buxton? An answer to both questions may be linked to the fact that the Tansleys had a holiday home ‘high up at West Malvern’. It seems likely that during the 1892 excursion she was introduced to the students in the party and formed a friendship with the Dale sisters. Thus, the next year, Mrs Tansley joined them, and her son, at the BAAS meeting.
After 1914, records of Elizabeth Dale’s life are again few, although it is known that she spent her last years living near Ventnor, on the Isle of Wight, dying in 1956 at the age of 88. She owed much to the tutelage of Harry Marshall Ward, but he had spotted an outstanding student with an exceptionally broad range of interests. Someone who, after his death, was perfectly capable of pursuing her own research.
Next read Maria Dawson, where references will be found or return to Women Inspired by Marshall Ward.